Previews: 19 Oct 2017

“All the right votes, but not necessarily in the right order”

Like the first two Thursdays of the month, 19th October 2017 sees eight by-elections, but it could have been more. There was a ninth by-election scheduled for today in the Haseley Brook ward of South Oxfordshire district, but when nominations closed the Conservatives’ Caroline Newton was the only candidate and she has therefore been elected unopposed. This column sends its congratulations to Councillor Newton. Of the eight remaining seats up for election this week, there are five Labour defences (three of which are in the city of Nottingham) and two Conservative defences; however, will all of those looking safe the focus is likely to be on Britain Elects’ favourite type of by-election, a free-for-all to replace an independent councillor in that most interesting of towns, Hartlepool. Three of the Labour vacancies arise from newly-elected MPs leaving their council seats behind to concentrate on their new careers in Westminster; as they join the ranks of the Commons we start this week by paying tribute to one former MP who has recently left us. Read on…


Lower Sheering

Epping Forest council, Essex; caused by the death of Conservative councillor Gary Waller at the age of 72.

One of the few councillors notable enough to merit his own Wikipedia page, Waller was a Conservative MP throughout the Thatcher and Major administrations. He gained the marginal seat of Brighouse and Spenborough from Labour in 1979, and when that seat was abolished in the 1983 boundary changes he gained the Keighley seat from Labour, holding it until 1997. Waller never got off the backbenches, but during the 1992 Parliament was chairman of the House of Commons Information Committee, which oversaw Parliamentary IT and the House of Commons Library. The Major administration was never short of scandal, and Waller’s contribution to that was to have an affair – resulting in a son – with Sir Marcus Fox’ secretary. Waller moved from Yorkshire to Essex after his parliamentary career ended, being elected to Epping Forest council in 2011 and serving as chairman of the Harlow branch of the Conservative party. Away from politics his interests included history and his collection of Jaguar cars.

Gary Waller ended his days as a councillor in the Lea Valley. Despite its presence in the Harlow parliamentary seat, Lower Sheering doesn’t really have all that much to with Essex: the village of Lower Sheering itself is essentially an extension of the Hertfordshire town of Sawbridgeworth, most of the ward has a Sawbridgeworth postcode (CM21) and the ONS classifies it as within the Cambridge travel to work area. Sawbridgeworth station, on the West Anglia main line, lies just outside the ward boundary. Lower Sheering saw strong population growth in the 1980s and 1990s and has a blue-collar commuter demographic, with high employment levels.

This adds up to a Conservative ward as you might expect. Waller was first elected here in 2011, defeating former councillor Charlotte Edwards who had won a by-election in November 2009 but sought re-election as an independent. At the most recent election to this ward in 2015 Waller defeated Labour 70-30 in a straight fight, and in May the Tories polled over 78% in the local county division (North Weald and Nazeing).

Defending for the Tories is Paul Stalker, a Sheering parish councillor (although for Sheering Village parish ward, which is not part of this district ward). Labour have withdrawn from the fray, but the Liberal Democrats have ensured a contested election by selecting Epping resident Ingrid Black who stood here at the 2009 by-election.

Parliamentary constituency: Harlow
Essex county council division: North Weald and Nazeing
ONS Travel to Work Area: Cambridge
Postcode districts: CM17, CM21, CM22

Ingrid Black (LD)
Paul Stalker (C)

May 2015 result C 821 Lab 354
May 2011 result C 420 Ind 185 LD 87 Grn 49
November 2009 by-election C 302 LD 93
May 2007 result C 409 LD 131
May 2003 result C 207 LD 80
May 2002 result C 244 Lab 72 LD 45


Meopham North

Gravesham council, Kent; caused by the death of Conservative councillor John Cubitt who had served since winning a by-election in October 2011.

For our by-election south of the Thames this week we stay in commuter territory. Meopham (pronounced MEPP-ham) is a village in the Kentish North Downs five miles south of Gravesend, on the Chatham Main Line to Victoria; this makes it a well-off area popular with London commuters, and the ward is part of the London Travel to Work Area. The village is rather strung out from north to south, and as the name suggests this ward is the northern half of Meopham parish. Within this ward lies the whole of Meopham village with the associated settlements of Meopham Green and Meopham Station.

Meopham North is the first of two wards this week to have previously appeared in Andrew’s Previews, and has a very high councillor attrition rate: this is the fourth by-election here since the last boundary change in 2003, and that’s without counting the 2007 ordinary election which was postponed to June following the death of a candidate. The October 2011 by-election here was the subject of an opinion poll – believed to be the first ever opinion poll for a UK local by-election – conducted by Survation for ITV Meridian with a sample size of 300. Headline figures were C 52% UKIP 26% Lab 20% LD 2%; the figures for third and fourth proved to be off with the Lib Dems eventually finishing third, but the poll did correctly indicate that UKIP would come a strong second at a time when that was still a remarkable occurrence. UKIP were still second at the 2015 ordinary election, in which the Conservative slate beat them 57-22. The Tories did even better in May’s county elections in the local division (Gravesham Rural).

Defending for the Conservatives is Gary Harding, who hasn’t let his deafness put him off trying for a political career: he was the UKIP candidate for Lewisham West and Penge in the 2015 general election, and in May’s county elections was on the Conservative slate in the Labour-held division of Northfleet and Gravesend West. This should be a safer berth. The official UKIP candidate is Tina Brooker, a legal secretary and pro-streetlight campaigner who is from Gravesend; she fought the Gravesend East county division in a by-election last year and in May’s ordinary election. Also standing are regular Labour candidate Doug Christie and the Lib Dems’ John Death.

Parliamentary constituency: Gravesham
Kent county council division: Gravesham Rural
ONS Travel to Work Area: London
Postcode districts: DA3, DA13

Tina Brooker (UKIP)
Doug Christie (Lab)
John Death (LD)
Gary Harding (C)

May 2015 result C 1594/1336 UKIP 611 Lab 576/371
Dec 2014 by-election C 419 UKIP 204 Lab 108 LD 36
Oct 2011 by-election C 648 UKIP 462 LD 148 Lab 112
May 2011 result C 1220/1051 Lab 497/389
June 2007 postponed poll C 681/682 LD 200/178 Grn 104 Lab 59/57 Loony 31
Jan 2004 by-election C 643 Lab 105 LD 58
May 2003 result C 892/887 Lab 243/216 Grn 190


Basford;
Bestwood; and
Bulwell Forest

Nottingham council; caused respectively by the resignation of Alex Norris who is now MP for Nottingham North, the resignation of Mick Wildgust and the death of Alan Clark at the age of 66. All three were Labour councillors.

Having got the southern starters out of the way, the main course this week is three by-elections for adjoining wards in northern Nottingham. We’ll start alphabetically with the ward closest to the centre, Basford, which was incorporated into Nottingham in 1877 and still retains much of its original Victorian housing in the Old Basford area. Basford once had three railway stations serving it; it now has none but is served by five stations on Nottingham’s tram system. They are Wilkinson Street, Basford, David Lane and Highbury Vale on the main route together with Cinderhill on the Phoenix Park branch. The ward’s main traditional industries were soap and brewing, with the Shipstones brewery closing in 1991 and Cussons making Imperial Leather in Basford until 2005 This is a highly multi-ethnic area: Basford ward makes the top 15 wards in England and Wales for mixed-race population (8.5%).

Further out along the tram line is Bulwell Forest ward (served by Bulwell and Bulwell Forest tram stops), a more traditional working-class area although still with a relatively high Black and Asian population. Bestwood ward lies to the north-east, between Arnold Road and Queens Boulevard, and is based on the notorious 1930s Bestwood Estate and the rather quieter 1950s-60s Bestwood Park Estate. Bestwood ward still has very high levels of unemployment and social housing and makes the top 80 wards in England and Wales for mixed-race population. Just outside the Bestwood ward boundary, and supplying a large number of jobs in the area, is the Nottingham City Hospital which provides cancer care services for the region and has a national reputation for shoulder surgery.

As the map above suggests, all three of these wards are safe Labour under current political conditions. Bulwell Forest possibly has the most interesting history: in 2003 Labour won all three seats with independent candidate Karen Kemp and the Conservatives close behind, and in the 2007 election the Conservatives gained one of the Labour seats. Basford ward voted Lib Dem in 2003 but then the Lib Dem vote fell apart and the ward was an easy Labour gain in 2007. One of the Labour councillors for Basford stood for re-election as an independent in 2011 and got nowhere, his seat being easily held for Labour by Alex Norris whose political career started there. At the most recent city election in 2015 shares of the vote in Basford ward were 48% for Labour, 20% for the Conservatives and 16% for UKIP. Labour beat UKIP 56-22 in Bestwood ward, while Bulwell Forest ward had the lowest Labour share in this group: 46%, to 20% each for UKIP and the Conservatives.

Defending Alex Norris MP’s seat for Labour in Basford ward is Nick Raine, a Unite officer representing teachers in the East Midlands and Yorkshire. The Conservative candidate is Bradley Wing, an entrepreneur in his early 20s. UKIP have secured something of a coup by selecting Bill Ottewell, a Labour councillor for this ward from 2011 to 2015; in 2015 he sought election in Clifton North ward and was defeated. Completing the Basford ballot paper are Zeb Brigham for the Green Party and Rebecca Proctor for the Liberal Democrats. Some of Basford’s voters may be pleased to note that their polling station is a pub: the Mill and the Headstocks, both on Bagnall Road, have been pressed into the service of democracy.

In Bestwood ward the councillor being replaced is Mick Wildgust, Lord Mayor of Nottingham in 2011-12, who is standing down on health grounds after being first elected in 2007. Labour are hoping his replacement will be Georgia Power, a recent Nottingham University graduate and women’s officer for Labour’s Nottingham South branch. UKIP have reselected Francesco Lari who fought the ward in 2015, and the ballot paper is completed by the Conservatives’ William Scott, the Greens’ Liam McClelland, David Bishop of his Bus-Pass Elvis Party – who may have hung up his blue suede shoes as far as parliamentary by-elections are concerned, but will still turn out for a local by-election in his native Nottingham – and the Lib Dems’ Christina Morgan-Danvers. Voters in polling district BESE are asked to note that their usual polling place at the Robin Hood Primary School is not available and they will vote instead at the Bestwood Park Community Centre.

Finally we come to Bulwell Forest ward where the late councillor, Open University lecturer Alan Clark, had had 29 years’ service on Nottingham city council, first being elected for the predecessor Byron ward in 1988. His council career focused on energy and environmental issues, and he was responsible for setting up the UK’s first council-owned energy company, the not-for-profit Robin Hood Energy. Clark’s wife Eunice Campbell, another councillor for the ward, survives him.

Defending Bulwell Forest for Labour is Cheryl Barnard, who runs a property leasing company. UKIP have reselected Tony Blay who fought the ward in 2015. The Tory candidate is Karen Kemp, who was runner-up in this ward in the 2003 election as an independent. Completing the Bulwell Forest ballot paper are Andrew Jones of the Green Party and Callum Southern of the Liberal Democrats.

Basford

Parliamentary constituency: Nottingham North
Postcode districts: NG5, NG6, NG7, NG8

Zeb Brigham (Grn)
Bill Ottewell (UKIP)
Rebecca Proctor (LD)
Nick Raine (Lab)
Bradley Wing (C)

May 2015 result Lab 3523/3306/2754 C 1449/1006/925 UKIP 1162/1143/1059 Grn 885 TUSC 200
May 2011 result Lab 2436/2197/2126 C 795/765/701 Ind 567 LD 547/536/407
May 2007 result Lab 1991/1919/1831 C 1128/1114/932 LD 689/589/582
May 2003 result LD 1390/1382/1319 Lab 1258/1162/1103 C 756/733/695 Socialist Alliance 71/54

Bestwood

Parliamentary constituency: Nottingham North
ONS Travel to Work Area: Nottingham
Postcode district: NG5

David Bishop (Bus-Pass Elvis)
Francesco Lari (UKIP)
Liam McClelland (Grn)
Christina Morgan-Danvers (LD)
Georgia Power (Lab)
William Scott (C)

May 2015 result Lab 3409/2804/2799 UKIP 1341/1147/1109 C 971/897/730 Grn 405/342
May 2011 result Lab 2451/2066/2062 C 748/724/672 LD 497
May 2007 result Lab 1775/1367/1362 C 837/806/785 LD 666
May 2003 result Lab 1753/1615/1462 C 648/614/601

Bulwell Forest

Parliamentary constituency: Nottingham North
ONS Travel to Work Area: Nottingham
Postcode districts: NG5, NG6

Cheryl Barnard (Lab)
Tony Blay (UKIP)
Andrew Jones (Grn)
Karen Kemp (C)
Callum Southern (LD)

May 2015 result Lab 3198/2997/2820 UKIP 1382/1376/1197 C 1367/1354/1319 Grn 523 LD 292 TUSC 143
May 2011 result Lab 2956/2938/2714 C 1402/1259/1122 UKIP 336/248/194 TUSC 212
May 2007 result Lab 1944/1930/1835 C 1914/1794/1543 LD 540 UKIP 394
May 2003 result Lab 1582/1519/1497 Ind 1344 C 1051/1040/885 LD 513


Carholme

Lincoln council; caused by the resignation of Labour councillor Karen Lee, who is now MP for Lincoln. A former nurse at Lincoln County Hospital, Lee had served on Lincoln city council since 2003 and was Mayor of Lincoln in 2012-13.

For our second “new MP” by-election of the week we travel east from Nottingham to Lincoln. The Labour gain of Lincoln was one of those results which would have come as a complete surprise before the Tory general election campaign hit the rocks, and reflects the fact that Lincoln is not representative of the county to which it gives its name. Boundary changes confuse the issue here: Carholme was a student ward at the time of the 2011 census, but since then it has seen strong population growth which led to boundary changes for the 2016 election. The new boundaries saw the University of Lincoln campus transferred to Boultham ward, so the census stats are clearly no longer comparable. That left Carholme ward entirely north of the River Witham, running west from the city centre (Steep Hill, the High Street and Brayford Pool lie on the ward boundary) along the Carholme Road. Most of the buildings are Victorian or older, but the ward also includes a rather isolated 21st-century housing estate along Long Leys Road.

Carholme is a traditionally Labour ward, although the Lib Dems gained a seat from Labour in 2007, held it at the 2008 election and were only seven votes away from defeating Lee in 2010 on a general election turnout. After that the Lib Dem vote in Carholme melted away and their seat was regained by Labour in 2012. In 2016 – the only previous contest on these boundaries – Labour beat the Conservatives here 57-20. Over the last twelve years the area has also consistently returned Labour councillors to Lincolnshire county council, which has its main offices in the ward.

Defending for Labour is Lucinda Preston, head of English at Carre’s Grammar School in Sleaford, who fought the Lincolnshire Police and Crime Commissioner election in 2016. The Conservatives have reselected Kateryna Roures Salvador, a University of Lincoln student who fought the ward in 2016 and the Carholme county seat in May. Also standing are Benjamin Loryman for the Greens and James Brown for the Lib Dems.

Parliamentary constituency: Lincoln
Lincolnshire county council division: Carholme
ONS Travel to Work Area: Lincoln
Postcode districts: LN1, LN2, LN5

James Brown (LD)
Benjamin Loryman (Grn)
Lucinda Preston (Lab)
Kateryna Roures Salvador (C)

May 2016 result Lab 1176/1076/1029 C 414/341/311 Grn 293/223/180 LD 176


Astley Mosley Common

Wigan council; caused by the resignation of Labour councillor Joanne Platt, who is now MP for Leigh. She had served since 2012.

For our North West by-election we are on the Lancashire coalfield. Roughly halfway between Wigan and Manchester, Astley takes its name from the Old English for “eastern clearing”, due to its location to the east of Leigh. This was one of the main centres of the Lancashire coalfield: over twenty pits were sunk in Astley and its twin town of Tyldesley. Astley Green Colliery was the last of these to close, in 1970, and its site next to the Bridgewater Canal is preserved as a museum with Lancashire’s last remaining pit headgear. A landmark for those passing by on the East Lancashire Road, which since the 1930s has provided a fast road link from here to central Manchester, although the advent of the misguided bus and the strange things Salford council have done to the Crescent have rather reduced that advantage in recent years. Nonetheless Astley has a Manchester postcode (M29) and has attracted some commuters as one of the more fashionable parts of the Leigh constituency. Much of the acreage of the ward south of the East Lancs Road is taken up by Chat Moss, still a desolate peat bog into which few venture.

This ward was created in 2004 out of the former Bedford-Astley and Tyldesley East wards, which were both rock-solid Labour, so it must have been a shock when the 2004 election returned just one Labour councillor to two Liberal Democrats. The Lib Dems held a seat in 2006 but lost a seat to Labour in 2007, finishing third behind the Conservatives. The Tories built on that good performance to gain the ward in 2008, meaning that Astley Mosley Common had voted for all three main parties in as many years.

Labour narrowly gained the remaining Lib Dem seat in 2010, and then the advent of Coalition led to a sharp drop in the Tory vote and the disappearance of the Lib Dem vote. Joanne Platt duly regained the Tory seat in 2012 with a vote share of 70%, and was re-elected in 2016 with 51% of the vote to 24% each for the Tories and UKIP. In May’s Greater Manchester mayoral election her predecessor as MP for Leigh, Andy Burnham, beat the Tory candidate here 69-22.

Defending for Labour is Paula Wakefield, a caseworker in Platt’s constituency office who got into politics through campaigning about contaminated blood. The Conservative candidate is David Stirzaker, a local resident who fought the ward in 2015; he is a boatmaster on the canals and a trustee of the Astley Youth brass band. UKIP have selected local resident Alan Hogg. Completing the ballot paper are Andy Prentice for the Green Party and Stuart Thomas for the Liberal Democrats.

Parliamentary constituency: Leigh
ONS Travel to Work Area: Manchester
Postcode districts: M28, M29, WA3

Alan Hogg (UKIP)
Andy Prentice (Grn)
David Stirzaker (C)
Stuart Thomas (LD)
Paula Wakefield (Lab)

May 2016 result Lab 1548 C 739 UKIP 731
May 2015 result Lab 2478 C 1804 UKIP 1306 Grn 290
May 2014 result Lab 1812 C 867
May 2012 result Lab 1810 C 534 LD 243
May 2011 result Lab 2028 C 1158
May 2010 result Lab 2339 LD 1894 C 1635
May 2008 result C 1207 Lab 1014 LD 634
May 2007 result Lab 1048 C 821 LD 665 Grn 218
May 2006 result LD 1472 Lab 865 C 674
June 2004 result Lab 1501/1122/1095 LD 1367/1259/1173 Grn 870

May 2017 Greater Manchester mayoral election Lab 2029 C 646 LD 92 EDP 77 UKIP 57 Grn 44 Farmer 14 Aslam 2


Seaton

Hartlepool council, County Durham; caused by the resignation of independent councillor Paul Thompson due to work commitments. He had served since 2010.

They say you should save the best till last, and for this week’s column that is most certainly the casex. Welcome to Seaton Carew, known to the wider world for three things: the Hartlepool nuclear power station, the controversial Able UK shipbreaking facility, and the curious case of John Darwin, who faked his own death in a canoeing accident here in 2002.

That’s a completely unfair description for a lovely place. Let’s start again. Welcome to Seaton Carew, known to the wider world for three things: its wide sandy beach, for being developed as a seaside resort for Quakers from Darlington, and for the Teesmouth nature reserve. This is an area of sand dunes, marsh and mudflats where lapwings, curlew, wading birds and seals thrive against the most industrial backdrop imaginable (think Blade Runner with seals, and then remember that Ridley Scott went to college in Hartlepool). Yes, there really are seals at Seal Sands, don’t let anyone tell you otherwise.

The beach at Seaton is of high quality and deserves to be better known. There’s history in that beach: a submerged forest lies along the shoreline, the wreck of a collier brig appears out of the sands every so often, and each high tide washes up some coal from an open seam out to sea. (Don’t worry, there’s plenty of beach left!) Some people still make a living collecting seacoal from the beach at Seaton. Recent regeneration work has demolished some of the more dilapidated shelters on the seafront, but the 1938 Art Deco bus station has survived and is a bit of a hidden gem. And it’s not just the bathing that brings tourists: Seaton Carew golf club, opened in 1874 as England’s tenth-oldest club, is described as one of the most challenging links courses in the British Isles, and in 2014 hosted the Brabazon Trophy – England’s premier men’s amateur strokeplay championship.

For all this tourism, this is Teesside and it’s industry that brings money into the place. The golf club got a windfall in the 1970s thanks to the construction of the Ekofisk gas pipeline across its land from the North Sea gas fields to the Teesside Refinery, still within the ward at Greatham although refining no longer takes place here. The power station and Able UK have already been mentioned; next to them was a zinc smelter (appropriately at the end of Zinc Works Road) whose site is now occupied by Frutarom, a company making chemicals for the food industry. The chemicals don’t end there: next to Able’s shipyard is the Tioxide works at Greatham, where my father once had a job. (The staff smoking area was known as “Oxygen Corner”, for reasons which may be obvious if you ever go there.) On the landward side of the railway line is the Hartlepool Pipe Mill, the UK’s largest steel pipe mills, recently sold by Tata Steel in a transaction which will create 100 new jobs. With all this heavy industry, it’s no surprise to see that Seaton ward – on its 2011 boundaries – made the top 40 wards in England and Wales for apprenticeship qualifications. Boundary changes introduced in 2012 expanded the ward west of the railway line into very deprived parts of the old Fens and Rossmere wards.

Have I sold Seaton Carew to you yet? You really must go. If you’re still not convinced then, remembering this is supposed to be a piece about local by-elections, have a look at Seaton’s politics which are like Hartlepool’s politics as a whole: fragmented and thoroughly weird. At the first election to Hartlepool as a unitary borough in 1995 Seaton elected two Labour councillors and an Independent Conservative. One of the Labour councillors, Cath Hill, sought re-election in 1998 as an independent, losing her seat to the Conservatives; but got back in 1999 by picking up the Independent Conservative seat. The Conservatives gained a second seat from Labour in 2000, an election where Labour lost control of Hartlepool council due to an apparent electoral pact between the Tories and Liberal Democrats. In retrospect, it was at this point – more than two years before the Monkey Mayor Stuart Drummond came on the scene – that Hartlepool’s local politics started to get strange. Labour got a seat back in 2002, defeating the Conservatives, but that was the last time that Seaton voted Labour.

Boundary changes in 2004 saw all three seats up for election, and Seaton ward elected two independent councillors, Mike Turner and Cath Hill, and one Conservative, seafront chippy owner David Young who narrowly held off UKIP. Turner was the outgoing Labour councillor and, judging from the 2004 result,clearly had a huge personal vote. Young lost the Conservative seat to a third independent, Paul Thompson, in 2010.

All three independents – Turner, Thompson and Hill – were re-elected in 2012 on the present, expanded boundaries. Mike Turner resigned shortly afterwards to care for his wife, and the by-election was won easily by Kelly Atkinson, standing for a localist slate called Putting Hartlepool First. Cath Hill died shortly before the 2014 local elections, leaving her seat open, and it was gained by UKIP in a fragmented result: 30% for UKIP, 25% for independent candidate Sue Little, 20% for Putting Hartlepool First and 17% for Labour. Thompson was re-elected in 2015 in an even more fragmented result, with majorities of 18 votes over UKIP and 36 votes over Labour: vote shares that year were just 24.1% for Thompson, 23.6% for UKIP, 23.2% for Labour and 13% each for the Conservatives and Little. At the most recent election in 2016 Putting Hartlepool First held their by-election gain and you’ll not be surprised to hear that the result was fragmented: they had 28% to 26% for Little, 23% for UKIP and 13% for Labour. Since the EU referendum win UKIP’s electoral performance has been generally appalling at every level of government, but one of the few bright spots for the Kippers among the doom and gloom of this period was a by-election gain in Hartlepool in October 2016. The party has a long and relatively impressive track record in Hartlepool, going back to the parliamentary by-election in 2004. It will be interesting to see if the relatively good Kipper organisation in the Pool can buck the trend, or whether the UKIP vote here wil be like the last tide’s batch of seacoal – stranded short of the high-water mark.

To take the five candidates in order of the most recent election, Putting Hartlepool First have nominated Leisa Smith who runs a catering company; outgoing councillor Thompson has signed her nomination papers. Sue Little, another businesswoman who launched a dial-a-ride bus service in Hartlepool this year, is hoping that it will be fourth time lucky for her as an independent candidate. The UKIP candidate is Karen King. Labour have selected Ann Marshall, a former Hartlepool councillor (Rossmere ward, 2004-12) who stood here in the 2012 by-election and stood in Fens and Rossmere ward last year. Completing the ballot paper is Conservative candidate Mike Young. Goodness knows what will happen here, but at this stage possibly the safest prediction is that we can expect another win on a low share of the vote.

Parliamentary constituency: Hartlepool
ONS Travel to Work Area: Hartlepool
Postcode district: TS25

Karen King (UKIP)
Sue Little (Ind)
Ann Marshall (Lab)
Leisa Smith (Putting Hartlepool First)
Mike Young (C)

May 2016 result Putting Hartlepool First 586 Ind 540 UKIP 482 Lab 278 C 123 Grn 55
May 2015 result Ind 1004 UKIP 986 Lab 968 C 537 Ind 530 Grn 149
May 2014 result UKIP 562 Ind 473 Putting Hartlepool First 385 Lab 329 C 141
October 2012 by-election Putting Hartlepool First 441 Lab 261 Ind 193 UKIP 128 C 94 LD 31
May 2012 result Ind 1168/883/769 Putting Hartlepool First 328/172 Lab 287/274/237 UKIP 243 C 158


If you liked this post, please consider buying the book! Andrew’s Previews 2016, containing many more previews like these, is now available from Amazon.